Category Space Ship One

Flight Aborted (4GC)

The fourth flight of SpaceShipOne was scheduled to be a glide flight. Figure 7.4 shows preparations being made the day before the flight. Melvill had successfully opened more than 60 percent of the subsonic flight envelope on the previous flight. This included speeds from stall to 150 knots. Now it was planned to open up the envelope even further.

The flight envelope indicated all the ways SpaceShipOne could safely fly, which included variations and combinations of speed, altitude, attitude, and other factors. The crews flew the easiest stuff, as the pilots and engineers gained confidence and began to nail down the flying characteristics. Step by step, they pushed the boundaries as they flew the vehicle more aggressively to reveal its limitations.

However, twenty minutes prior to separation, the launch had to be aborted due to a GPS malfunction with the avionics system. Figure 7.5 shows the mated pair during the aborted test flight prior to landing. Initially designated as 4G and 31L for SpaceShipOne and White Knight, respectively, the flight numbers were modified to 4GC and 31LC as a result of the abort. But it was possible to complete some systems testing prior to landing.

Flight Aborted (4GC)

Flight Test Log Excerpt for 4GC

Date: 27 August 2003

Flight Number Pilot/Flight Engineer

SpaceShipOne 4GC Mike Melvill

White Knight 31LC Brian Binnie/Cory Bird

Objective: Second glide flight of SpaceShipOne. Flying qualities and performance in the spaceship feather mode. Pilot workload and situational awareness while transitioning and handling qualities assessment when reconfigured. As a glider, deep stall investigation both at high and low altitude and envelope expansion out to 200 knots and 4 g’s. Lateral directional characteristics including adverse yaw, roll rate effectiveness and control, including aileron roll and full rudder sideslips.

(source: Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, provided courtesy of Scaled Composites)

Flight Aborted (4GC)

Подпись: IFlight Aborted (4GC)с ; л

Fig. 7.4. SpaceShipOne and White Knight are poised before the fourth test flight. Planned as SpaceShipOne’s second glide flight, the flight had to be aborted midair. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by David M. Moore

к___________________ 7

Flight Aborted (4GC)

ґ

Fig. 7.5. It was necessary to abort the fourth test flight because of an avionics malfunction involving the global positioning system (GPS) prior to separation. However, before returning to Mojave, test pilot Mike Melvill completed some systems testing. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by David M. Moore

V___________________________________________________________________________

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)

On this day, the 47th anniversary of Sputnik, Brian Binnie was selected to pilot SpaceShipOne for the second of the two flights required to win the Ansari X Prize. Melvill, who had been a backbone of the program, had paved the way for Binnie only five days earlier. Melvill would now be there flying White Knight along with Matt Stinemetze as flight engineer.

Gone.

Flight Test Log Excerpt for 17P

Date: 4 October 2004

Flight Number Pilot/Flight Engineer

SpaceShipOne 17P Brian Binnie

White Knight 66L Mike Melvill/Matt Stinemetze

Objective: Second X Prize flight: again ballasted for 3 place and 100 kilometer goal (328,000 ft). (We also really wanted to break the X-15 354 kft [thousand feet] record.)

(source: Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, provided courtesy of Scaled Composites)

V___________________________________________________________

“He dropped me, and I dropped him,” Melvill said. “That was fun.”

White Knight and SpaceShipOne lifted off together at 6:49 a. m. PST on October 4, 2004, in the chill of the desert morning with the Sun rising. In an article Binnie wrote for Air <$_ Space, he echoed the thoughts of Melvill, “The program to develop and test Burt Rutan’s SpaceShipOne (SSI) had many different demands, but I can safely say the one that made the pilots uniformly uncomfortable was the hour – long wait in SSI while the White Knight carrier aircraft dragged it up to release altitude. During this time, there is little to do and the mind is somewhat free to wander.”

As the world watched, the pressure on Binnie was enormous. With the prize of $10 million on the line, Branson waiting down below poised to begin work on SpaceShipTwo, and the fact that it was ten months since the last time he flew SpaceShipOne, which resulted in a crash landing, Binnie had plenty to wrestle with inside his head. “For me personally, a problem or failure or inability to pull this off for whatever reason, the other side of that coin was a bottomless pit. It felt to me like an abyss.”

Tensions ran high on the ground, too. “I knew that if there would be any glitches, people would say that this is not ready for prime time,” Ansari said. “And it’s not ready for commercialization and all these things.”

But when it came time to launch, every trace of doubt or uncer­tainty disappeared with the first flash of the rocket engine. Binnie’s years of navy flying and skills as test pilot took control. At 7:49 a. m., an hour after takeoff, and 47,100 feet (14,360 meters), Stinemetze pulled the lever to drop SpaceShipOne.

Table 9.1 gives the transcript of the communication between Binnie and Mission Control from the moments before separation to when the feather was locked down after reentry.

“We had no reason to delay,” Binnie said. “So, as soon as I was separated, I armed and fired the rocket motor.”

Ignition occurred immediately, and off Binnie went. SpaceShipOne zoomed past White Knight close enough for Melvill and Stinemetze to hear the hybrid rocket engine, a spaceman’s version of buzzing the tower. Figure 9.10 shows SpaceShipOne beginning to make its turn toward space. After 10—12 seconds, Binnie was thinking, “Okay, I’m still alive. I’m still in the loop. I’m still managing this thing.” But as SpaceShipOne transitioned into supersonic flight, he relaxed. The hardest part was over.

“We wanted to get to the X Prize altitude and a secondary goal of trying to beat the X-15 record,” Binnie said. “So, we wanted lots of altitude. But we also wanted to exit the atmosphere without any rolls or gyrations or large body rates so that we didn’t scare off Branson and the whole SpaceShipTwo efforts. There was that dual-edge sword of precision flying on one side and performance on the other.

“We wanted to get the nose up to 60 to 70 degrees as quickly as we could, initially, a very aggressive turn,” Binnie continued. “Once we got there, we started slowing down the pitch rate on the vehicle so that we went from 60 degrees to about 80 to 82 degrees over the next 50 seconds or so. The bulk of the flight was just milking the nose between those pitch attitudes. And then the last 20 to 25 seconds was the start of a pull again to get to about 87 to 88 degrees nose up.”

г

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)Подпись: лFig. 9.10. Brian Binnie faced the toughest flight of his entire life on October 4, 2004. He hadn’t flown SpaceShipOne since the crash landing. Now he was behind the controls of SpaceShipOne while the world’s eyes watched his every move. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, video capture provided courtesy of Discovery Channel and Vulcan Productions, Inc.

s________________________ ;

The exhaust from SpaceShipOne s rocket engine streaking upward as the contrail from White Knight veers off to the left can be seen in figure 9.11.

Binnie continued, “The initial pitch attitude to 60 to 65 degrees meant you were going to take advantage of all that rocket motor energy that is available to you and convert that to altitude. And the pull-in endgame meant you were keeping angle of attack on the vehicle and making it less susceptible to rocket-motor asymmetry in the thin upper atmosphere, where you have a delicate balance between controlling those asymmetries with little aerodynamic control power to resist it.”

After 84 seconds, Binnie shut down the rocket engine when SpaceShipOne had reached 213,000 feet (64,920 meters), zipping upward as fast as Mach 3.09 (2,186 miles per hour or 3,518 kilometers per hour). Like a pot of gold at the end of a rainbow, $10 million waited at the other end of the ballistic arc.

“I went scooting right through the X Prize altitude and past the X -15 old record by 13,000 feet [3,960 meters] or so. I got to the point after rocket motor shutdown and the feather coming up, and I hadn’t touched any of the reaction control system yet to control body rates. The vehicle was just absolutely stable. I actually used reaction control to give myself a different view so I could take some pictures.”

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)C ^

Fig. 9.11. The contrail of SpaceShipOne streaks spaceward as the contrail of White Knight peels off to the left. Brian Binnie fired the rocket engine for 84 seconds, shutting it down at 213,000 feet (64,920 meters). Dan Linehan

V J

г ^

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)Fig. 9.12. Well past the boundary of space, Brian Binnie had entered the black sky. SpaceShipOne coasted to an apogee of 367,500 feet (112,000 meters), surpassing the X-15 altitude record of 354,200 feet (108,000 meters). Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by Scaled Composites

V J

Binnie reached an apogee of 367,500 feet (112,000 meters), which exceeded the Ansari X Prize requirements by nearly 7.5 miles (12 kilometers), and experienced weightlessness for more than 3.5 minutes. Binnie had a little time to take pictures, and figure 9.12 shows one of his photographs. In addition to taking photos, as figure 9.13 shows, he had the chance to do some zero-g testing on a miniature SpaceShipOne. Binnie did not release M&Ms in space as did Melvill, and it’s still unconfirmed whether Binnie ate his allotment during the captive-carry phase. Doug Shane would not speculate on the origin of several faint crackling sounds heard over the Mission Control radio.

Although weightless at apogee, SpaceShipOne had not truly escaped Earth’s pull. SpaceShipOne started to freefall and began to
accelerate, reaching Mach 3.25, which was the fastest speed it had ever reached on any of the flights. As SpaceShipOne descended into the thick atmosphere, air friction now decelerated it, and at 105,000 feet (32,000 meters), Binnie faced a peak force of 5.4 g’s pushing against his body.

As the g-forces subsided and SpaceShipOne slowed down below the speed of sound, Binnie retracted the feather at an altitude of 51,000 feet (15,540 meters). The video frames, at two-second intervals, in figure 9.14 show the transition of the feather mechanism from the extended position to the retracted position. After reentry into Earth’s atmosphere, the feather had done its job. The pair of pneumatic actuators, which can be seen connecting either side of the fuselage to the trailing edge of the

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)r~

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)Fig. 9.13. Brian Binnie’s trajectory was spot-on during the ascent. The hard part was over, now that gravity had taken over control of the trajectory. Binnie had 3.5 minutes of weightlessness to savor. He snapped photos and sailed a SpaceShipOne model back and forth across the cockpit. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, video capture provided courtesy of Discovery Channel and Vulcan Productions, Inc.

V_________________________________________________________

wings, pulled downward. This caused the feather to retract, making SpaceShipOne streamlined once more and readying it for the glide back to Mojave.

SpaceShipOne, now configured as a glider, drifted homeward. Figure 9.15 shows Sir Richard Branson, Paul Allen, and Burt Rutan spotting SpaceShipOne in the sky above Mojave.

The world watched SpaceShipOne gliding down for 18 minutes.

“I don’t know,” Ansari said, “maybe naively, I just felt that there was no more danger and everything would be fine or if there were any glitches or problems, they would be very much manageable. I wasn’t too worried because I had watched landings of SpaceShipOne a few times before.”

After only 24 minutes from being dropped by White Knight, SpaceShipOne’s wheels hit the runway for a perfect landing, as shown in figure 9.16.

“Oh, it was absolutely wonderful,” said the 434th human to reach space, summing up his spaceflight.

Once the nose skid brought SpaceShipOne to a stop and the door popped open, Binnie was instantly welcomed back by his wife as Rutan, Allen, and Branson congratulated him on the victorious flight. Towed by a pickup truck, SpaceShipOne paraded up and down the flightline in front of the thousands and thousands of cheering supporters as Binnie stood triumphantly atop, as shown in figure 9.17.

“The whole experience was very emotional for me,” Ansari said. “Even though I had nothing to do with the design and the hard work that the engineers and the team had put into building SpaceShipOne, I just felt like part of the team. I was just so proud and happy that they were successful, and that was the greatest joy to see that happen.”

Eight years after it was announced, the Ansari X Prize was finally captured, just like the Orteig Prize, first offered in 1919 and claimed in 1927. The difference was that aviation would not just take a giant leap into the air but would leap past where the air was thin to the beginning of space.

Г Л

Fig. 9.14. As SpaceShipOne fell back to Earth, the feather eased it into the atmosphere. At 51,000 feet (15,540 meters), Binnie retracted the feather, as shown by the sequence given at two-second intervals. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, video captures provided courtesy of Discovery Channel and Vulcan Productions, Inc.

ґ

Подпись: лFig. 9.15. Sir Richard Branson, Burt Rutan, and Paul Allen (left to right), search the sky and spot SpaceShipOne as it nears the end of its 24-minute journey up and down from space. X PRIZE Foundation

v___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)f

Fig. 9.16. Brian Binnie finished his flawless performance by making a perfect landing. After about a year and a half of flight testing, seventeen flights altogether, SpaceShipOne touched down on the runway for the last time. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, video capture provided courtesy of Discovery Channel and Vulcan Productions, Inc.

V_________________________________________________

г ^

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)Fig. 9.17. In a matter of days, not weeks, SpaceShipOne made two spaceflights. No other vehicle in the history of space travel had accomplished this feat. Brian Binnie’s performance not only restored his confidence in himself but made it clear to the world that the future of space travel was happening right here, right now. X PRIZE Foundation

Подпись: Figure 9.18 shows Peter Diamandis and Anousheh Ansari celebrating with Brian Binnie, Burt Rutan, Paul Allen, and Sir Richard Branson. “It was just a feeling of relief that everything had worked flawlessly,” Paul Allen recalled. “A mix of elation and relief I think is what I described at the time. And you are proud for Burt and his team. In the back of your mind you are thinking like maybe this does open the door for a lot of possibilities in the future in terms of private space tourism. I was just very excited and relieved, just an amazing mixture of emotions.” With the Ansari X Prize awarded, commercial space travel officially launched off. Diamandis’ vision of a new way of thinking about space flight became reality, and Rutan with his team from Scaled Composites provided the way. Eight years was a long race, but the accomplishments during this time frame far outreached what was once thought possible. Подпись: The will was now strong enough to overcome the energy barrier to space, much the way the mystical sound barrier was broken in the 1940s to usher in supersonic flight. Paul Allen saw to it that Burt Rutan would have the chance to show his stuff and prove to the world that the impossible wasn’t impossible. And Brian Binnie’s perfect performance flying SpaceShipOne, gave all the reason to Sir Richard Branson and his newly formed Virgin Galactic that commercial space travel was right. “Burt has the world’s greatest garage,” Paul Allen said. “We built a rocket in the world’s greatest garage, and we actually got into space and back, and everybody was safe. And it won a prize. It is hard to explain the excitement of that. And the crowds being there celebrating that with you was just amazing.”

___________________ J

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)r ; >

Fig. 9.18. SpaceShipOne had done it. Eight years after its announcement by Peter Diamandis and the X Prize Foundation,

Brian Binnie had captured the Ansari X Prize. Burt Rutan, Paul Allen, and the rest of their team had pulled off the seemingly impossible.

Now was the time to celebrate the historic accomplishment and also to revel in the wonderment as the door to space flung wide open.

X PRIZE Foundation

V__________________ )

Table 9.1 Transcript of SpaceShipOne’s Ansari X Prize-Winning Spaceflight

This transcript was prepared using video filmed during the second Ansari X Prize spaceflight attempt from inside the cockpits of SpaceShipOne and White Knight and from inside Mission Control. The spaceflight was called X2 because it was the second attempt required by the Ansari X Prize and also called 17P because this rocket-powered flight was the seventeenth time SpaceShipOne flew. White Knight lifted off with SpaceShipOne from Mojave’s Runway 30 at 6:49 a. m. PST on October 4, 2004. The entire spaceflight lasted 1.6 hours (wheels up to wheels down for White Knight). The time stamps are hours:minutes:seconds a. m., PST. The transcript runs from just before SpaceShipOne is dropped from White Knight to just past feather retraction and lock after reentry. Acronyms used are:

AFFTC: Air Force Flight Test Center at Edwards Air Force Base

AST: Federal Aviation Administration Office of Commercial Space Transportation

BB: Brian Binnie in SpaceShipOne

BR: Burt Rutan in Mission Control

DS: Doug Shane in Mission Control

MC: Staff in Mission Control

MM: Mike Melvill in White Knight

MS: Marc de van der Schueren in the Alpha Jet chase plane

Подпись: 137

SS1: SpaceShipOne

Time stamp and speaker

Dialogue

Notes

7:49:17 MM

"SCUM status?"

The Scaled Composites Unit Mobile (SCUM) was a mobile ground control station.

7:49:19 DS

"SCUM is go for release and ignition, elevons to go."

BB pushes the control stick forward, preparing for release.

7:49:22 MM

"Three. Two. One."

7:49:25 MM

"Release."

7:49:27 BB

"Release."

7:49:28 BB

"Armed."

7:49:28 BB

"Fire."

7:49:32 BB

"Good light."

7:49:37 DS

"Coming up ten seconds, Brian."

Rocket engine burn time at 10 seconds.

7:49:39 BB

"Copy."

7:49:42 DS

"Rates look good and low."

7:49:46 DS

"Okay, start the nose-down trim."

The trajectory must be timed in order to end up at zero angle of attack as late as possible.

7:49:49 DS

"Looking great at twenty seconds."

Rocket engine burn time at 20 seconds.

7:49:54 DS

"Doing okay?"

7:49:55 BB

V

"Doing alright."

(Source: Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, provided courtesy of Scaled Composites)

7:49:58 DS

"Copy that. Thirty seconds, a little nose up trim is probably okay now."

Rocket engine burn time at 30 seconds.

7:50:02 MM

"You look great."

7:50:07 BB

"Starting to settle out."

7:50:09 DS

"Okay, forty seconds."

Rocket engine burn time at 40 seconds.

7:50:10 DS

"The energy’s on the line. The trajectory looks good."

The actual trajectory is tracking with the predicted trajectory.

7:50:13 BB

"Copy."

7:50:16 DS

"Touch of nose up trim."

7:50:19 DS

"Fifty seconds."

Rocket engine burn time at 50 seconds.

7:50:21 DS

"Two hundred energy."

This reading stands for a projected altitude of 200,000 feet (60,960 meters) for SS1. It does not stand for SSI’s actual altitude. Both MC and AFFTC use energy altitude predictors to project the maximum altitude SS1 would reach if its rocket engine were to shut off and SS1 were to coast the remainder of the way up. The projected altitude gives an indication at any given time whether or not SS1 will reach the target altitude of 328,000 feet (100,000 meters).

7:50:22 DS

"A little right roll trim."

A slight correction is made to the trajectory.

7:50:26 DS

"Nose pitch up, Brian, nose up trim."

7:50:30 BB

"There is the shaking."

The liquid to gas transition, which occurs as the N20 begins to run low in the oxidizer tank, causes this to happen.

7:50:31 DS

"Okay."

7:50:33 DS

"Roll right."

7:50:36 DS

"Three hundred thousand."

The predicted altitude is 300,000 feet (91,440 meters).

7:50:41 DS

"Three twenty-eight."

The predicted altitude is 328,000 feet (100,000 meters).

7:50:44 DS

"Radar is three twenty-eight."

The predicted altitude is 328,000 feet (100,000 meters) as measured by AFFTC.

7:50:45 BB

"Copy that."

7:50:48 DS

"Three fifty suggest shutdown."

The rocket engine is still firing, and if it is shut down at this point, SS1 will coast to 350,000 feet (106,700 meters).

7:50:53 BB

"Roger. Shutdown."

BB lets the rocket engine burn an extra 4-5 seconds.

7:50:58 BB

"And the rates look good."

7:51:00 DS

"Okay. Copy that."

7:51:01 DS

"You are going to want to track north for the entry."

A box, approximately 2.5 square miles in size, is set by AST for SS1 to make the reentry.

7:51:03 DS

"You are just across the orange line on the south."

The orange line is an AST boundary.

г

7:51:05 DS

"Uh, you are good east, uh, east-west of Mojave."

7:51:08 ВВ

"Okay, I see that."

7:51:10 DS

"Okay."

7:51:14 DS

"Eighty-four seconds."

The rocket engine burns for a total time of 84 seconds.

7:51:15 DS

"Eighty-four seconds, the shutdown is clean and the feather is green."

7:51:19 BB

"Feather unlock."

7:51:24 BB

"Feather. . . moving."

7:51:27 BB

"RCS on."

The reaction control system (RCS) controls motion of SS1 in space.

7:51:28 DS

"Copy that, Brian. It’s moving, and it’s green."

The feather is extending upward.

7:51:30 DS

"CTN is a little warm but looking fine."

The CTN is the case/throat/nozzle assembly of the rocket engine.

7:51:33 DS

"RCS A looks nominal."

The pressure for the RCS looks good.

7:51:37 BB

"I show the feather up."

7:51:39 DS

"We do show the feather all of the way up now. It is green."

7:51:48 BB

"The trim is set."

7:51:49 DS

"Looks great."

7:51:51 BB

"And I’m upside down."

7:51:53 DS

"Okay."

7:51:57 DS

"You are going to want to orient northwest for the entry, Brian."

SS1 should be oriented so that it points toward Mojave.

7:52:00 BB

"Okay, Doug. Copy that, northwest"

7:52:02 DS

"Sound great. Feel good?"

7:52:04 BB

"I’m feeling great."

7:52:05 DS

"Copy that."

7:52:07 BB

"Better get the camera out."

7:52:09 DS

"Roger that."

7:52:14 BR

"X-15 record."

This comment is made in MC and not heard over the radio. SSI’s actual altitude is above the highest altitude reached by the X-15. The predicted altitude is no longer used.

7:52:16 DS

"X-15."

7:52:21 BB

"Outstanding."

7:52:22 MM

"That’s outstanding. I knew it."

)

(

7:52:37 BR

"Ten thousand feet over X-15."

This comment is made in MC and not heard over the radio.

7:52:48 BB

"Boy, it’s really quiet up here."

7:52:59 DS

"Okay, flight is through this position coming downhill through three fifty."

The actual altitude of SS1 is 350,000 feet (106,700 meters).

7:53:03 DS

"And current position is five southwest."

7:53:06 DS

"Correction, five south of the bull’s-eye."

The bull’s-eye is the center of the AST box.

7:53:08 DS

"Looks like the entry point is between main base and north base."

This is to let the chase planes know that reentry will occur between Mojave Air and Space Port and Edwards Air Force Base.

7:53:17 DS

"Brian, if you can keep it upright for GPS, that’s good."

7:53:19 DS

"And, again, orient northwest please for the entry."

7:53:25 BB

"Copy that, Doug."

7:53:36 DS

"And Brian, a little blip of right yaw trim would be good."

7:53:43 DS

"That looks great."

7:53:45 DS

"Doing okay?"

7:53:48 BB

"I’m doing great, Doug. Uh, camera is, uh, stowed again."

7:53:54 DS

"Copy that, passing two six zero."

The actual altitude is 260,000 feet (79,250 meters).

7:54:03 BB

"And it’s northwest you want for the heading right?"

7:54:06 DS

"Affirmative."

7:54:09 DS

"That’ll point you back at high key."

High key is a glide mode of the TONU.

7:54:21 DS

"All systems are green here, Brian."

7:54:22 DS

"Don’t worry about temps in the back end."

7:54:24 DS

"We’re looking good here."

7:54:26 MS

"Alpha’s got a visual."

The Alpha Jet chase plane spots SS1.

7:54:27 BB

"Okay, here comes the g’s."

7:54:29 DS

"Copy that."

7:54:31 DS

"One hundred fifty thousand."

The actual altitude is 150,000 feet (45,720 meters).

7:54:37 BB

"There’s three."

BB is referring to the number of reentry g’s.

7:54:41 DS

"Max Mach is past three two six."

SS1 reaches a maximum of Mach 3.25.

7:54:45 BB

"Five g’s."

7:54:58 DS

"Peak g is passed."

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)

 

7:55:00

BB

"Copy that."

7:55:02

DS

"You’re looking great on glide range."

7:55:03

DS

"Coming through seventy five thousand."

7:55:12

DS

"Ok, we have had no GPS."

7:55:13

DS

"So, you are a little higher than your indication Brian."

7:55:15

DS

"We are showing seventy but radar is looking like seventy-five now."

7:55:20

DS

"And, uh, roll right if you can, that would be good."

7:55:23

BB

"Okay."

7:55:27

DS

"Okay, there is seventy thousand radar."

7:55:29

DS

"Feather at your discretion."

7:55:31

DS

"Uh, might give it another couple seconds."

7:55:32

BB

"It feels a little, ah, loosy goosy right now."

7:55:35

DS

"Copy that."

7:55:40

DS

"You are going to want to get the roll trim back to neutral as you defeather."

7:55:45

DS

"Radar altitude sixty-three now, sixty-three thousand."

7:55:48

BB

"Okay, I feel good about the feather."

7:55:50

DS

"Yeah, we do here."

7:55:55

DS

"RCS off when you can."

7:55:58

BB

"RCS is off."

7:55:59

DS

"Copy."

7:56:00

DS

"You are going to want to start a right turn to the north as soon as you recover."

7:56:04

BB

"Copy."

7:56:08

DS

"Radar shows fifty-four thousand."

7:56:17

BB

"I show the feather locked."

7:56:18

MC

Cheering in mission control.

7:56:19

DS

"The feather is locked and it is green."

 

The actual altitude is 75,000 feet (22,860 meters).

 

DS is reporting altitude in thousands of feet.

 

The actual altitude is 70,000 feet (21,340 meters).

 

There is no hurry, as BB is in good glide range, and the vehicle should fly better.

 

The actual altitude is 63,000 feet (19,200 meters).

 

The actual altitude is 54,000 feet (16,460 meters).

 

X2: Winning the Ansari X Prize (17P)

SpaceShipOne’s journey had not ended with the Ansari X Prize, although the mission and the destination had substantially changed. SpaceShipOne was about to embark on two of its longest flights ever, one across the United States and one across the Solar System. Tyson V. Rininger

The Cash Prize

This was all a lot of careful planning, but $ 10 million of prize money does not just materialize out of thin air. This figure does not even include all the expenses needed to run the competition. All totaled, it was a lot of spacebucks. The early conceptual drawing in figure 2.11 gives an indication of the broad, forward thinking of the ambitious X Prize.

In 1995, Diamandis established the X Prize Foundation in Rockville, Maryland, with the help of Maryniak, Lichtenberg, and Colette M. Bevis. That same year Diamandis met Doug King, the president of the St. Louis Science Center, who offered to help raise $2.5 million if the X Prize Foundation would relocate there. St. Louis embraced Diamandis, and with its aviation heritage, the decision to move was an easy one.

During a fundraiser in St. Louis, a local businessman named Alfred Kerth reminded Diamandis that Charles Lindbergh created the Spirit of St. Louis Organization. This organization was a group of ten business leaders who contributed a total of $25,000 to purchase the aircraft used by Lindbergh to cross the Atlantic Ocean. “And Spirit of St. Louis—the airplane—was named after that organization,” Diamandis said. “So Kerth said, ‘Let’s get one hundred people to contribute $25,000 or more from the St. Louis region and call them the New Spirit of St. Louis Organization. It will be the funding mechanism to kick this whole thing off.’ ”

On May 18, 1996, three days before the anniversary of Lindbergh’s historic flight, under the St. Louis Arch, the X Prize was announced. Guests of the ceremony included twenty astronauts; Dan Golden, the administrator of NASA at the time; the Lindbergh family; and Burt Rutan, who on that day made his interest clear. The race was on, and teams had until January 1, 2005, to claim the X Prize.

By 2001, the X Prize was still not fully funded. Bob Weiss, movie producer and vice-chairman of the X Prize Foundation, proposed the idea of a hole-in-one insurance policy to Diamandisrize. With a hole-in-one insurance policy, an insurance company essentially bets against an event happening. This is not uncommon in golf tournaments, where a player can win a car or a great deal of money if he or she makes a hole-in-one on a specific hole on the golf course. If no player makes a hole-in-one, then the insurance company keeps the insurance premiums paid by the tournament organizers and pays nothing out. However, if a player does make a hole-in-one, then the insurance company pays the check.

f ■ ^

The Cash PrizeFig. 2.11. The vision of Peter Diamandis and the X Prize Foundation was to rekindle the public’s interest in space and foster the development of private spacecraft that would open the door to the stars for more than just the very limited number of astronauts from government-sponsored programs. X PRIZE Foundation

___________________ J

The X Prize Foundation moved ahead with the insurance idea, but premiums were not inexpensive. “I would have to pay out $50,000 every other month sometimes and a large balloon payment at the end,” Diamandis said. “And there were times that I would literally have a week in which to raise $50,000 or I would lose all the premiums I had paid earlier.”

After being in existence for six years, the X Prize was much more fragile than most people knew. It was very difficult to raise money to support the day-to-day operations, let alone funding the $10 million prize money.

During the height of Erik Lindbergh’s involvement, he had become the vice president of the X Prize Foundation. In 2002, he retraced his grandfather’s famous flight on the 75th anniversary of the historic crossing of the Atlantic Ocean by the Spirit of St. Louis. Flying a modern Lancair Columbia 300, named the New Spirit of St. Louis, Eric Lindbergh flew the same flight path but did so in a little more comfort and safety. He could actually see out the front windshield and did not require the use of a periscope. He averaged 184 miles per hour (296 kilometers per hour), and the flight lasted 19.5 hours com­pared to 108 miles per hour (174 kilometers per hour) and 33.5 hours for his grandfather’s transatlantic flight.

“When I decided to fly across the Atlantic in the Columbia, I did it really to support X Prize,” Erik Lindbergh said. “That was the main thrust of it. That was one of many efforts by individual directors that saved X Prize at a specific period in its history.”

Almost one million dollars was raised, with a majority going to the X Prize. But that wasn’t enough to keep it from ditching before reaching the final destination.

Anousheh Ansari

Anousheh Ansari’s fascination with space and the stars began when she was a little girl living in her native country of Iran. At sixteen, she and her family immigrated to the United States. Ansari, shown in figure 2.12, did not speak English, but education was extremely important to her family. She would pick up the language, a bachelor’s in electronics and computer engineering, and a master’s in electrical engineering on the way to co-founding Telecom Technologies, a multi – million-dollar telecommunications company.

In all this time, her desire for spaceflight never wavered. “Because I didn’t become a professional astronaut, I have been looking for other ways,” Ansari said. “So, even before meeting Peter Diamandis, I did a lot of looking around on the Web and other places, trying to see what was happening with the space program and if there would be an opportunity for civilians to fly. I had visited the X Prize website and a couple of other websites where they were advertising for tickets for suborbital flights. I did a little bit more research and found out they were basically just doing a lot of conceptual design of these suborbital vehicles to compete in the X Prize. I believed that it would happen soon enough, and probably my first experience or first chance would be on suborbital flight.”

In 2001, Fortune magazine ran an article about the forty wealthiest people under the age of forty. Ansari made number thirty-three on the list, ahead of Jim Carrey at number thirty-six and Tiger Woods at number forty. But in a sidepiece, Ansari made it clear to the world that space was her number-one goal. There, Ansari had expressed “her desire to board a civilian-carrying, suborbital shuttle.”

“I read that like three times,” Diamandis said. “So, I convinced myself that it really said suborbital flight.”

The Cash Prize

г >

Fig. 2.12. Captivated by space from her childhood days, Anousheh Ansari never stopped believing that some day she would make it to space. In 2004, the Ansari family was officially named the title sponsor of the X Prize. Two years later, Anousheh Ansari’s dream came true. Prodea Systems, Inc.

All rights reserved. Used under permission of Prodea Systems, Inc.

V_____________________________________ )

Diamandis and Lichtenberg immediately contacted Ansari to arrange a meeting. “From the first moment we sat across the table and started to talk about it, Peter had us sold,” Anousheh Ansari said, speaking of her and her bother-in-law, Amir Ansari, who had shared the same excitement about space.

Ansari began backing the X Prize in 2002. However, it wasn’t until May 2004 that the Ansari family was announced as the title sponsor. “Our sponsorship was absolutely needed for X Prize to succeed,” she noted. “At the time we joined the organization, if we had decided not to, I don’t know if they would have survived. We felt that we couldn’t let that happen. This was too valuable. It was difficult to put together such a good group of people again. The momentum was right. We couldn’t just let it go. And at the same time, the reason we did it was because we love flying to space. And it wasn’t like I want to do it just once, and we knew there were millions of people around the world that felt the same way. We wanted to do something to help build an industry so this would become something that would be available, and you can do it again and again and again.”

Gathering Momentum

Just as the X Prize Foundation faced challenges to keep the prize going, the individual teams faced similar problems. The biggest of these was funding. It wasn’t so much of a technology challenge that the teams had to overcome—the technology to get into space had been around for a long time. The teams were not starting from square one. In fact, with modern materials and computers, a technical leap wouldn’t likely be the limiting factor.

Rutan and his team certainly seemed to be in a very good position. “Some viewed him as the frontrunner,” Diamandis recalled. “Lessons of history are that sometimes the frontrunner doesn’t win. In the Orteig Prize for example, the frontrunner was Admiral Byrd, the first person to fly to the North Pole. He crashed on liftoff. This young upstart, unknown to the rest of the world, Charles Lindbergh, comes along and wins the competition.”

A total of twenty-six teams registered for the Ansari X Prize, representing seven different countries, but not every team that applied made it in. “We probably turned away about half the appli­cations we received,” explained Diamandis. “We required the teams to really demonstrate to us the seriousness of their team and effort. They had to demonstrate by virtue of the people who were involved, the companies who were involved, and they had to show us the primary concept.

“We had numerous teams apply with antigravity and UFO tech­nology. My answer was simple: ‘My office is on the second floor. If you can float up to the second floor, I’m happy to register you.’ ”

Some of the teams that competed did get vehicles into the air and performed flight tests to various degrees, while some hadn’t had the resources necessary to get their programs very far off the ground. Two of the top contenders were Steve Bennett’s Starchaser out of England and Brian Feeney’s da Vinci Project out of Canada, refer to figure 2.13 and figure 2.14, respectively.

“Steve Bennett was the first person to fly an X Prize vehicle, or a vehicle with X Prize logos on it, called Nova, which was the first launch in like thirty years out of the UK,” Diamandis said.

Launched on November 22, 2001, Nova weighed in at 1,643 pounds (747 kilograms). It was unmanned, but the capsule was designed to fit one person. Starchaser had actually developed and launched rockets beginning in 1993, well before the Ansari X Prize was announced, so it was one of the more established teams.

“I didn’t want to apply for the X Prize competition and come across as someone who was ill equipped to deal with it,” said Steve Bennett, the team leader of Starchaser. “It took me about a year to get all my ducks in a row. And we made the application, and Peter accepted it no problem.”

A bigger vehicle was still needed, since the Ansari X Prize required it to fit three people. “We went through a number of ideas and over the years the design evolved,” continued Bennett. “And what happened was it just got simpler and simpler and simpler. So, we

Ґ л

Gathering MomentumFig. 2.13. Having launched over sixteen large rockets since 1993, Starchaser was one of the more experienced teams competing for the Ansari X Prize. Even after the Ansari X Prize, Starchaser rocket development continues.

In 2007, Starchaser won a study contract from the European Space Agency (ESA) to further investigate reusable launch vehicles for space tourism. Courtesy of Starchaser Industries

V_________________ )

Подпись: #

( ^

Fig. 2.14. To avoid the high cost of developing a ground-launched rocket

or a carrier aircraft, Brian Feeney’s da Vinci Project built the world’s largest balloon, capable of holding 3.70 million cubic feet (0.10 million cubic meters) of helium, to lift its Wild Fire rocket to a launch altitude of 70,000 feet (21,340 meters). Brian Feeney, the da Vinci Project

V___________________ J ended up with a very simple ballistic rocket. We discovered that the easiest and simplest and safest way to do this would be to just launch a ballistic rocket just like they launched Alan Shepard in back in ’61. Straight up, straight down, and a capsule that can carry three people. And that’s pretty much it.”

The rocket had three main components: a booster, which was the Starchaser 5 rocket powered by liquid oxygen (LOX) and kerosene fuel engines; the capsule, which was called Thunderstar; and the launch escape system.

Figure 2.15 shows Bennett standing next to the Nova 2 after piloted drop tests from 10,000 feet (3,050 meters) were conducted.

Bennett admitted, “The biggest challenge was, I guess, raising the finances, because the technology to do this kind of thing has been around since the 1950s, possibly even the 1940s.”

So, the team had to be creative. Back in 2000, they had pre-sold two of the seats for when they would first attempt the Ansari X Prize.

Gathering Momentum

Подпись:Ґ

Fig. 2.15. Steve Bennett stands next to Nova 2, which was drop tested from an altitude over 10,000 feet (3,048 meters) to test the parachute-recovery system. For each test, a pilot manned the capsule, which was then dropped out the back of a cargo plane. Courtesy of Starch a ser Industries

v______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Bennett said of the two prospective passengers, “They wanted to basically support the project. And they wanted to fly on the first flight. We got three seats in the capsule. The only condition they made was, ‘Here’s the money, Steve. We’ll give you the money. We’ll give it to you up front, and we’re not even going to come back to you. We don’t care whether it takes a year or ten years. You tell us when it’s ready. We’re not going to hassle you. There is only one condition.’ And the one condition was the third seat had to be occupied by me. Okay. So, they knew I wasn’t a nutcase. They knew that I wanted to do this project and that I wanted to come home to my family.”

The competition really began to heat up midway through 2004, when two teams each secretly notified the X Prize Foundation that they were going for it. Diamantis recalled, “People have to give both confidential notice within 120 days and public notice within 60 days of their attempt to fly. So, we had gotten confidential notice of Rutan’s flight date, and then a few weeks later we got confidential notice from Brian Feeney that the da Vinci Project was going to attempt a flight.

“We thought for a moment we might have to mount flight com­petitions in two separate nations, and funding that and doing a good job of judging was going to be a challenge for us.”

Feeney, who had an aerospace company in the 1980’s that did life – support systems, read an article about the announcement of the Ansar і X Prize while living in Hong Kong. “That was the catalyst for me,” he said. “I stopped what I was doing right away at the time.” Feeney had constantly looked for opportunities that would take him to space. He rallied one of the largest volunteer efforts for a technology project in Canadian history while using a very unconven­tional approach to reach space. At first he looked into developing a carrier aircraft like Scaled Composites had done. “We wanted to do that even before we knew what they were doing. But the cost to do that was just prohibitive. We knew we’d be challenged just to get the money to build the spaceship itself,” Feeney said.

“A ground-launched vehicle required about four times as much energy, thrust, everything else, compared to an air-launched vehicle, whether it was balloon, as in our case, or an aircraft or whatever

Gathering Momentum

ґ

Fig. 2.16. Teams had to give a 120-day confidential notice to the X Prize Foundation that they were going to make an attempt at the Ansari X Prize. As the deadline loomed, Scaled Composites gave its secret notification, and a few weeks later, the da Vinci Project also gave notice. The da Vinci Project finally got a big chunk of funding from GoldenPalace. com, but it proved to be too late in the game. Brian Feeney, the da Vinci Project

Подпись:v______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

means of getting to that altitude. At the end of the day, I thought the balloon-launch system was a good compromise with the much higher cost of developing a ground-based launch rocket.”

A rocket called Wild Fire, pointing up at 75 degrees, would be tethered to the world’s largest reusable helium balloon. Made of polyethylene, the balloon, measuring in at 150 feet (46 meters) in diameter and 200 feet (61 meters) in length, could contain 3.70 million cubic feet (0.10 million cubic meters) of helium. It would only be 15 percent full at liftoff but would expand as it ascended. The da Vinci Project had successfully tested a scaled-down version of their launch balloon before constructing the final launch balloon.

Figure 2.16 shows the Wild Fire rocket at only 80 percent complete. At an altitude of 70,000 feet (21,340 meters), which is higher than any launch aircraft could fly, Wild Fire would detach and use a hybrid fuel rocket engine to soar into space.

“I never felt in the long run that it was an ideal commercial propo­sition, because the balloon is subject to weather and a multiplicity of things. But it is a cost-effective way for a short program to demon­strate viable technology,” Feeney said.

Threads of Rocketry

Robert Goddard built and launched the very first liquid-fuel rocket in 1926, shown in figure 2.17, and is now considered the father of American rocketry. Yet when he first published theories about reach­ing the Moon using a rocket, he drew ridicule, so much so that he fled to the remoteness of Roswell, New Mexico, to continue his pioneer­ing research. Ironically, it was prewar Germany that seemed to take his work more seriously than did his own country.

But Goddard still had a few pretty important believers in his work. Charles Lindbergh had recognized that wings and propellers could

Threads of Rocketry

ґ

Fig. 2.17. Robert Goddard was a pioneer in rocketry. In this photo from 1926, he stands next to his invention, the very first liquid-fueled rocket. His breakthroughs were, unfortunately, not enough to shield him from relentless ridicule when he asserted that a large enough rocket could reach the Moon. NASA-Marshall Space Flight Center

Threads of Rocketry
Threads of Rocketry

(

Fig. 2.18. Charles Lindbergh (right) understood early on that airplanes had limitations. He was fascinated by rocketry because he knew this would be the next step. A kindred spirit, Lindbergh helped Robert Goddard (center) to get funding from the Guggenheim family. This photograph from 1935 shows Harry F. Guggenheim (left) visiting for a rocket launch. NASA-Headquarters

V___________________ J

Ґ Л

Fig. 2.19. The first man-made object to reach the edge of space, the V-2, was designed and built by Germany during World War II. Thousands and thousands of these ballistic missiles rained down on cities, with Antwerp and London being the targets of the vast majority. After the war, this vengeance or terror weapon became the foundation of the intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) and space programs of the United States and Soviet Union. NASA-Marshall Space Flight Center

V_____________________________________ J

carry an aircraft only so high. Because of this, Lindbergh was very inter­ested in rocketry and in Goddard’s work. Lindbergh was able to help secure funding for Goddard from the wealthy Guggenheim family. Figure 2.18 shows Lindbergh together with Goddard and his benefac­tor for the launch of one of Goddard’s more advanced rockets.

Right after World War II, when the German rocket scientists who worked on the V-2 rockets left for the United States or Russia, the United States asked Lindbergh to go to Germany and assess what was
left of the V-2 program. Figure 2.19 shows a V-2. It was not only a weapon of war, but it also was the foundation upon which the U. S. space program was built. Even an Ansari X Prize team, Canada’s Red Arrow, used it as the basis for their spacecraft.

So, early on, Charles Lindbergh was exposed to the work of Wernher von Braun. And it was von Braun who helped the United States to reach the surface of the Moon. It is hard not to see all the connections and parallels between this and the present.

Threads of Rocketry

SpaceShipOne may look like an airplane, but it is actually a combination of a missile launching from an aircraft, a spaceship maneuvering above the atmosphere, and a glider drifting down to Earth. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by David M. Moore

Space Ship One

I

want to apologize first off to any of my former English teachers who will have heart failure upon hearing that I actually wrote a book. I think I spelled my doom when I put a poem of mine on the first page of my master’s thesis. It wouldn’t have been so bad if my thesis was about art or literature, but it was about making superconductors with lasers and analyzing them with x-rays and electron beams. Fortunately, this book I write now is not a literary masterpiece, so, any such resulting cardiac irregularities shouldn’t last long or will perhaps be particularly mild.

With that disclaimer out of the way, I’d like to get started thanking some pretty fantastic people because without them I would have never been able to pull off a book like this. It has been a long and not so straight­forward journey to get to this point. There are more people to thank than I can reasonably do so on this page. It’s funny how things in life sometimes fall into place after a chain of events occurs that no one could have ever predicted in a million years. That’s what it’s all about, I guess.

I started writing for the California International Airshow’s event program in 2003 thanks to Cindy Rogers. I soon became editor and publisher working for Ginny Brown, who stood behind me and allowed me to create an award-winning event program in just three years. But I was far from alone in this. I met Tyson Rininger during this time. His wonderful photos filled the event programs from cover to cover. It was Tyson who got me on board with MBI. It is impossible to express my full appreciation. I am very fortunate to have been able to include Tyson’s photos of SpaceShipOne’ s first spaceflight and trip to Oshkosh.

I had the opportunity to write about SpaceShipOne and the Ansari X Prize for the Airshow. Lilian, Ray, and Cheryl hooked me up with VIP access during X2, which gave me the chance to met Burt Rutan, Paul Allen, Peter Diamandis, Anousheh Ansari, and Sir Richard Branson. In addition, this book would be nowhere if it wasn’t for the tremendous support of Dave Moore from Vulcan. Dave was Paul Allen’s managing director for Tier One. He was there from the beginning for the construction and test flights of SpaceShipOne by Scale Composites. Vulcan contributed a majority of the images used in this book, and Dave shot many of them.

When I made the transition from engineering to writing, David Gitin, a creative writing instructor at Monterey Peninsula College and an incredible poet, was critical to my successful transition. His friend­ship has been invaluable. I left engineering in 2000 with one goal in mind, to write a book. Along the way, not one of my family and friends told me I was mad. They may have thought it, but at least they kept it to themselves. Mom, Dad, Steve, Rob, Jen, Joe, James, Vik, Patty, Zaheer, Pranita, Norma, Charo, Maria, Manuel, Kim, Jerrold Kortney, and, of course, the Princess of the Bottom of the World, thank you so much for understanding.

Last, it’s very difficult to express my amount of gratitude toward MBI and my editor Steve Gansen. Writing this book was more challenging than I could have ever envisioned. Steve was vital in guiding me through the process and helping me reach a dream.

My best thoughts and wishes to you all.

Space Ship One

ш ■— J

W *-’*£ і

ШЯ^^Г’ ^0 .^к

Foreword

Flying the Spaceflight Mission

T

he objective was clear: a suborbital spaceflight above 328,000 feet (100,000 meters). But this mission was far from being straightforward. SpaceShipOne was groundbreaking. And although getting off the ground wasn’t too difficult, being able to return safely to the ground with the spacecraft intact required facing some pretty tough challenges. Three test pilots, Brian Binnie, Mike Melvill, and Pete Siebold, each flew SpaceShipOne during flight testing and handled the curves, and sometimes spirals, thrown their way. “Well, it is kind of a scary little thing to fly,” said Mike Melvill of the spacecraft he piloted for the first six flights and four subsequent others.

Figure 3.1 shows SpaceShipOne and White Knight waiting for launch in the early morning sunlight.

A carefully designed vehicle flown by a highly skilled pilot could tame the perilous environment and extreme forces, but it wasn’t easy. SpaceShipOne flew a total of seventeen times during its pursuit of space and the Ansari X Prize: three captive-carry flights, eight glide flights, three powered fights within the atmosphere, and three suborbital spaceflights. The combined flight time for these was 4 hours, 11 minutes, and 4 seconds, while the total burn duration was S minutes and 47 seconds. The spaceflight profile flown by SpaceShipOne is shown in figure 3.2.

White Knight would lift off the runway at Mojave Airport with SpaceShipOne slung below. And as the pilot anxiously awaited separation, all he could do was

( л

Fig. 3.1. With SpaceShipOne’s oxidizer tank filled the day before a launch and a fully fueled CTN (case/throat/nozzle) installed, SpaceShipOne and White

Knight undergo preflight preparations while illuminated by the early morning Sun. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by Scaled Composites

Подпись:

Flying the Spaceflight Mission

v______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

hang on until launch altitude. Upon separation, SpaceShipOne s rocket engine fired and boosted the pilot several times faster than the speed of sound. Since the rocket engine’s fuel was rubber, it gave a whole new meaning to burning rubber. But when the rocket engine shut down, after burning 76—84 seconds, the spacecraft was still only half the distance to apogee and had to coast the remaining way through the ever-thinning atmosphere.

On the way back down, SpaceShipOne’s feather ensured a safe reentry back into Earth’s atmosphere. When the craft was no longer falling at supersonic speeds, the feather retracted. SpaceShipOne, now a glider, descended to Mojave Airport for a horizontal landing, just like an ordinary airplane. Table 3.1 shows the mission profile for each of SpaceShipOne’s suborbital spaceflights.

For a spaceflight, the duration of the entire mission was only 1.6 hours. This was the time it took White Knight to take off, release

Table 3.1 SpaceShipOne’s Suborbital Spaceflight Mission Profile

1. Liftoff of SpaceShipOne mated to White Knight

2. Captive-carry to launch altitude

3. SpaceShipOne separation from White Knight

4. Supersonic boost to space

5. Coast to apogee

6. Freefall from apogee

7. Supersonic reentry into the atmosphere

8. Descent with feather still up

9. Gliding descent back to runway

10. Horizontal landing

ч__________________________________________ J

Подпись: 53 nmFlying the Spaceflight MissionПодпись: ~r

Fig. 3.2. After White Knight lifted off with SpaceShipOne mounted below, it spiraled up to a launch altitude of about 47,000 feet (14,330 meters), where SpaceShipOne then separated, ignited its rocket engine, and boosted to an apogee above 100 kilometers (62.1 miles or 328,000 feet). SpaceShipOne reentered the atmosphere with its feather deployed, then reconfigured into a glider for landing at Mojave. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, provided courtesy of Scaled Composites

V___________________________________________ J

SpaceShipOne, and then land. However, the spacecraft flew for about 24 minutes only, making it back from space and touching down even before White Knight did.

Enter Citizen Astronauts

E

scaping from Earth will not always be astronomically expensive; contrary to the impression created by a Saturn launch, the energy needed to reach space is remarkably small.

“About eight hundred pounds of kerosene and liquid oxygen, costing some twenty-five dollars, will liberate enough energy to carry a man to the Moon. The fact that we currently burn a thousand tons per passenger indicates that there is vast room for improvement.

“This will come through the space refueling, nuclear propulsion and, most important of all, the devel­opment of reusable boosters, or ‘space ferries,’ which can be flown for hundreds of missions, like normal aircraft. We have to get away, as quickly as possible, from today’s missile-orientated philosophy of rocket launchers which are discarded after a single flight.”

When I wrote these words in July 1969, the Apollo 11 astronauts were on their way to the Moon.* The Space Age was barely a dozen years old, and travelling to space required so much money and effort that only the governments of the richest countries could engage in it.

But the early years of space exploration were driven by different considerations: both national space agencies and TV networks seemed to love the massive firework displays at rocket launches. Indeed, witnessing a Saturn V take off could be a moving experience—if we overlooked the fact that it was a grandiosely wasteful way to travel anywhere (each Apollo mission cost around two hundred million in 1960s dollars).

So, even as I covered the Moon Landings for CBS television, I was already looking ahead to a time when space travel would make more economic sense. In my essay, I envisaged that the true Space Age would dawn sometime after 1985, “. . . and projects which today are barely feasible will become not only relatively easy, but economically self-supporting.”

I added: “The closing years of this century should see the beginnings of commercial space flight, which will be directed first towards giant manned satellites or space platforms orbiting within a thousand miles above the Earth’s surface.”

Well, in those heady days of Apollo, I couldn’t have anticipated all the detours and distractions of the 1970s that delayed our optimistic projections. Politics and economics have taken their toll, but looking back, I’m happy to note that I was off by only a decade or so.

Commercial space flight is now beginning to be technologically feasible and will soon become economically viable. The rise of citizen astronauts has already begun—this time, I doubt if politics can hold up progress because it is no longer so closely tied to the fluctuating interests and resources of national governments.

SpaceShipOne: An Illustrated History chronicles a key milestone in the race to take private citizens and pri­vate enterprise to space. It’s the story of how a group of determined and passionate aerospace designers— and their financiers—pulled off one of the most remarkable accomplishments in our conquest of gravity.

In that process, they won the ten-million-dollar Ansari X Prize founded by my friend Dr. Peter Diamandis to galvanize private enterprise and technological innovation in space travel. The prize was modeled after the twenty-five-thousand-dollar Orteig Prize, offered in 1919 by hotelier Raymond Orteig, to the first pilot to fly nonstop between New York and Paris. An unknown airmail pilot named Charles Lindbergh finally won this challenge in May 1927, flying a single-engine aircraft named Spirit of St. Louis. That feat won him instant fame and spawned the commercial aviation industry that changed our world beyond recognition.

And here’s an interesting coincidence. In 1987, I received the Lindbergh Award presented annually for those seeking a balance between technology and nature. The winner in 2000 was Burt Rutan, who went on to design SpaceShipOne with generous backing from Microsoft co-founder (and science fiction enthusiast) Paul Allen.

Burt and I are connected in other ways. I am intrigued to read that Burt’s boyhood imagination was sparked by watching Wernher von Braun on TV talking about the exploration of the Moon and Mars. Wernher was a good friend who took to diving on my suggestion—I told him that the best simulation of weightlessness was achieved underwater. And a few years ago I found out, from his long-time secretary, how Wernher had used my 1952 book, The Exploration of Space, to convince President Kennedy that it was possible to land men on the Moon.

While writing this, I came across Burt’s remark in Popular Mechanics (September 2007): “If we make a courageous decision like the goal and program we kicked off for Apollo in 1961, we will see our children or grandchildren in outposts on other planets.”

Fortunately, we need not rely solely on governments for expanding humanity’s presence beyond the Earth. The Ansari X Prize has succeeded in spurring commercial astronautics, and I hope governments will not stand in the way. I am following with much interest the emergence of a new breed of “astropreneurs” who are trying out new technologies, business models—and indeed, building a whole industry—without relying on government funding.

In that sense, space travel is returning to where it started: with maverick pioneers dreaming of journeys to orbit and beyond, some carrying out rocket experiments in their own backyards. Burt and his team have been a great deal more successful than Robert Goddard ever was in his lifetime (and, thankfully, no one is ridiculing Burt the way they did with Goddard).

Yet, today’s astropreneurs like Paul Allen and Burt Rutan are driven by the same spirit of enquiry, adventure, and exploration that sustained Lindbergh and Goddard. This, then, is the inside story of how citizens reclaimed space.

Liftoff to Separation

SpaceShipOne, with its landing gear retracted, was rolled on a dolly underneath White Knight and then raised using a hand crank. The top of SpaceShipOne attached to a two-point pylon that was mounted on the belly of White Knight. Two hooks inside the pylon, fore and aft, clamped onto SpaceShipOne, securing the vehicles together, as shown in figure 3.3. Heating ducts from White Knight to SpaceShipOne also ran through the pylon. The wings of SpaceShipOne were further secured by braces running down from White Knight. The clearance between the two was only a meager 1 foot.

The optimum time to launch from Mojave Airport was at day­break. Figure 3.4 shows a predawn preflight briefing, which reviewed the mission readiness and addressed any last-minute concerns. After White Knight, carrying SpaceShipOne, rolled out of the Scaled

Liftoff to Separationr ; л

Fig. 3.3. SpaceShipOne attached to White Knight at several points. A pylon underneath White Knight housed two hooks that fit into two rings on top of SpaceShipOne. A brace between each set of wings also helped to stabilize SpaceShipOne and keep it from swaying back and forth. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by David M. Moore

V__________________ J

Liftoff to Separation

Liftoff to SeparationLiftoff to Separation

г ^

Fig. 3.4. Early in the morning before each test flight, a preflight briefing was held so that the test pilots, ground crew, and Mission Control could review the details of the flight plan and receive updates on the status of the vehicles and the weather conditions. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by Scaled Composites

V___________________________________________

( ; t

Fig. 3.5. White Knight and SpaceShipOne taxi to Mojave Airport’s Runway 30. Located less than eighty miles northeast of Los Angeles, Mojave Airport became the first inland spaceport and the first public spaceport licensed by the FAA. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by Scaled Composites

V__________________ )

( ; >

Fig. 3.6. Inside Mission Control, the flight director, Doug Shane (seated

front row center), was the point person on the ground who communicated directly to the pilots aboard SpaceShipOne and White Knight during all phases of the mission. The Mission Control staff monitored all aspects of SpaceShipOne based on the instrument and video data transmitted by the craft. Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photograph by Scaled Composites

v___________________________________________ J

Composites hangar and final preparations were completed, the two vehicles taxied out to the runway. Figure 3.5 shows White Knight and SpaceShipOne getting ready for takeoff. Once in the air, White Knight headed 40 miles (64 kilometers) to a release box, an area that had been designated by the FAA.

Early in the program, the target for the separation altitude was

50.0 feet (15,240 meters). However, both the characteristics of the air, more specifically the density, and the performance of White Knight, or lack thereof, favored a separation altitude closer to

47.0 feet (14,330 meters). For this first stage of the ascent, White Knight spiraled up at a rate of about 700 feet per minute (210 meters per minute). And by the time the vehicles reached 45,000 feet (13,720 meters), the vehicles were above about 85 percent of the atmosphere.

“We fly up there on White Knight, and that is a really long period of time. It is close to an hour to get up there,” Melvill said.

“I really hated the ride up there,” he continued. “No one wants to talk to you. They think you need to sit there and concentrate on what you are about to do. I really would have liked someone to distract me and have a conversation about something else, because an hour is a long time to sit there and worry about what’s going to happen.

“You start getting close to the drop zone and close to the altitude. Then you go through a pretty extensive checklist setting the airplane up. You trim it 10 degrees nose up, so that when it drops off, it holds its nose up.”

Liftoff to Separation
Watching for the slightest abnormality, Mission Control carefully monitored the flight data and video transmitted by SpaceShipOne during the entire flight, as figure 3.6 shows.

It was possible to rotate the entire horizontal stabilizer on each of the tail booms. Adjusting it with 10 degrees nose-up trim would help ensure that SpaceShipOne didn’t go into a dive once it detached from White Knight. This setting was also necessary to help force the nose up once the rocket engine fired, enabling SpaceShipOne to move from horizontal flight to nearly vertical flight.

Figure 3.7 shows a close-up of SpaceShipOne during the captive-carry.

The procedure for the airborne launch of the rocket-powered second stage from the carrier aircraft was pretty simple. Even before the 1920s, flying vehicles had been dropped by larger flying vehicles. And NASA extensively used motherships for dropping X-planes and even for flight testing the Space Shuttle (refer to figure 3.8 and figure 3.9, respectively).

White Knight had to remain steady with its wings level. The pilot in SpaceShipOne began the sequence by arming part of his release system. In the cockpit of White Knight, a yellow light then came on. White Knight would arm next, giving another yellow light. At that point, the release handle inside White Knight became “hot.” A crew member in the backseat pulled it to retract the hooks. White Knight shook with a big bang as the spring-loaded hooks came to a sudden stop. SpaceShipOne dropped away as White Knight surged upward.

“There is an instant feel of you climbing,” said Pete Siebold about flying White Knight during this separation. “You lost almost half your weight. You were at 1 g and it jumped up to 1.6 g’s the second you pulled the release handle.”

Siebold flew SpaceShipOne three times, but all the test pilots pulled double duty when it came to flying. During flight tests with SpaceShipOne, one of the other SpaceShipOne pilots always flew White Knight.

г л

Liftoff to SeparationLiftoff to SeparationFig. 3.8. Carried to a height of

45,0 feet (13,720 meters) by a NASA B-52, the North American X-15 dropped from the wing at a speed of 500 miles per hour (800 kilometers per hour). The X-15 would typically carry out one of two missions: high-speed hypersonic (faster than Mach 5) test flights or high-altitude test flights. NASA-Dryden Flight Research Center

V J

Г Л

Fig. 3.9. The Space Shuttle Enterprise launches from the top of a NASA 747 Shuttle Carrier Aircraft (SCA). During the test flight, Enterprise glided back down to Dryden Flight Research Center, so aerodynamic and control characteristics could be evaluated prior to an actual spaceflight. NASA-Dryden Flight Research Center

For safe separation from White Knight, as shown in figure 3.10, the pilot in SpaceShipOne pushed forward on the control stick. This briefly counteracted the trim setting on the horizontal stabilizer. So, instead of wanting to pitch up, SpaceShipOne dipped down to avoid re-contacting White Knight.

Gliding for about 10 seconds, SpaceShipOne grew quiet, since it was now out of earshot of White Knight’s engines. The pilot made some quick final checks with Mission Control.

“You have to get the motor started as soon as you possibly can because you are just teetering on the edge of a stall,” Melvill added. “You’ve got all
that rubber fuel at the back of the airplane.” The center of gravity for SpaceShipOne was very far back. If its nose pointed up too high, without the rocket engine going, a stall would develop that would cause the space­ship to lose aerodynamic control. A pilot could recover from this, but SpaceShipOne would have lost a good deal of altitude in the process.

A Secret Space Program

W

hen SpaceShipOne touched down on Mojave’s Runway 30 after its third flight into space, it not only won the Ansari X Prize, but it also, in a way, completed a journey that had started on two separate paths that intertwined along the way and then finally merged together in 2004. SpaceShipOne was a small, lightweight rocketship somewhat resembling NASA’s early X-planes but with elements of Burt Rutan’s distinct flair for the unique and unconventional. Figure 1.1 shows Burt Rutan with Doug Shane, the test flight director, and the three SpaceShipOne test pilots, Pete Siebold, Brian Binnie, and Mike Melvill.

On that day test pilot Brian Binnie did more than capture the Ansari X Prize. He captured people’s imagination and reignited the space-crazy in them. Back in 1927, Charles Lindbergh, who just barely cleared telephone lines after takeoff in pursuit of the Orteig Prize, crossed the Atlantic Ocean nonstop from New York to Paris and sparked a boom in aviation like none other. These two turn­ing points forever changed the way people looked up into the sky and saw them­selves flying free as the birds or high as the stars.

Without people there would be no flying machines. It is not the mechanisms of engine, fuselage, wing, and empennage that provide transport into the air and through the clouds: it is the people whose ideas, visions, and daydreams have taken flight and soared. Without the human mind, the greatest height reached would only be as high as the highest surface that could be climbed.

г л

A Secret Space ProgramFig. 1.1. Burt Rutan (top left), the SpaceShipOne and White Knight designer, and Doug Shane (top right), the test flight director, stand behind their test pilots, Pete Siebold, Brian Binnie, and Mike Melvill (left to right). Mojave Aerospace Ventures LLC, photo­graph by Scaled Composites

V___________ )

It is no coincidence that the breakthroughs in aviation have come from ingeniousness and inventiveness as early as Leonardo da Vinci’s drawings of flying corkscrews and birdlike flight suits, or even earlier when the ancient Greeks pondered the air around them. As ideas like these were being conceptualized, more often than not, peers would view such thinking as folly, insanity, or even sacrilege.

Thankfully, there are a few whose hides are thicker than most, whose resilience is more enduring than most, and whose passion burns brighter than most. And more importantly, there are some whose persistence in moving forward, even if it takes stepping back­ward at times, is unwavering. It is not enough to be a great thinker. The genius lies in the execution. As inventor Thomas Edison is famous for saying, “Genius is one percent inspiration, ninety-nine percent perspiration.”

But these factors are no longer enough in this day and age. In centuries past, it may have been sufficient for just one person to cultivate a dream, from beginning to end, into fruition. But in today’s ever changing, ever more complicated society, often a wheel with only one cog will not provide the grip needed to take hold of an idea and spin it into something magical. It is only when the sprocket has gathered enough teeth that it can truly turn and move forward in a synchronicity of movement.

Burt Rutan

In 1965, Elbert L. “Burt” Rutan found himself in the backseat of an F-4 Phantom trying to figure out how to regain control as the fighter jet whirled around in circles in an unrecoverable flat spin. At the time, the Phantom was one of the U. S. Air Force’s frontline fighters. Under the right set of conditions, though, pilots could enter a flat spin where the only way out required the use of their ejection seats. A total of sixty-one aircraft had been lost because of this, and Rutan’s job was to determine a way to recover from this disastrous condition.

Fresh out of college, it was certainly a dream job for someone who had craved a challenge. Born in Portland, Oregon, in 1943 and raised in Dinuba, California, southeast of Fresno, he had been flying model airplanes that he designed and built since he was a young boy.

“None of those things were kits,” Rutan said. “They were original designs.” He entered model-airplane competitions during high school while also learning to fly. His models took him to the nationals, and he brought home trophies.

“I was of course fascinated by space,” Rutan recalled. “I listened to the Alan Shepard flight on the radio as I was driving to my college to interview.”

Rutan attended California Polytechnic University, where he would receive his bachelor of science in aeronautical engineering. In 1964, he was one a very few students, the only one from his college, selected to attend the CalTech Space Technology Summer Institute. During this time the United States continued to lag behind the Soviet Union in the space race. Yuri Gagarin, aboard Vostok 1, had become the first man in space three years earlier, and it would be yet another five years until Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin would set foot on the Moon.

The U. S. space program was hungry for engineers during this electrified time. It seemed natural that someone like Rutan would have his sights set on Apollo manned Moon missions.

Rutan remembers his boyhood imagination being stirred by watching television programs where Wernher von Braun, who headed Germany’s V-2 program but was now leading NASA’s Saturn V rocket development, talked about the exploration of the Moon and Mars with Walt Disney.

“Von Braun was a big hero of mine because of the Disneyland television show in 1955,” Rutan said. “Those programs were enormously compelling to me as a twelve-year-old because we didn’t know much about Mars in ’55. I have a college astronomy textbook that I had gotten a long time ago. It was written in ’53. It is interesting to read because they are debating what kind of life is likely to be on Mars and would there be a chance that it would be intelligent life. So, imagine yourself back in a time period when you believed there was vegetation there because you saw the colors change in the telescopes.”

Rutan had a tough decision to make when it came time to leave college. Although the space program barreled forward, and opportunities
certainly waited for him, he was very skeptical about how and where he would fit in. “I felt I was so far behind on being able to come in and take a new idea and actually get it out there flying if I focused on spaceflight or manned spaceflight.”

He didn’t want to work on the space widget of the what-cha-ma-call – it subsystem. While this obscure part was indeed a piece of the puzzle that would have been necessary for launch, Rutan desired to really make a big impact and influence the big picture. Working for an airliner or fighter manufacturer didn’t interest him, for the same reason. “I’d be working on a bulkhead or a door.”

So, he turned in another direction. “I thought I could make a big dif­ference with general aviation, which I thought was archaic and frozen.” He felt that he’d have the opportunity to let his creativity fly, even if it wouldn’t be quite as high as if he worked for the U. S. space program. But Rutan’s competitiveness helped sway him in yet another direction.

“I couldn’t bring myself to go work on Cessnas while everyone I went to school with was on the way to the Moon. So, I made a compromise. I went into air force flight testing.”

This was by far the best decision Rutan could have ever made. Working as a civilian at Edwards Air Force Base in Mojave and spending six to ten months on an aircraft before moving to the next one, he learned what risks to take and what decisions to make when testing out new aircraft. This education, he felt, was critical for a designer.

“I’m out there evaluating the performance, flying qualities, safety, etc., of the top-of-the-line, brand-new military airplanes. I got to fly in them, measure data, and report on their performance.”

In the Phantom on that day in 1965 when it went into a flat spin, once Rutan and the test pilot were sure that the flat spin was unre­coverable, they deployed a special recovery parachute that forced the large fighter jet out of the spin. “I’ve done the only flat spin in an F-4 that did not have an ejection.” But the very next flight, with a different test engineer in the backseat, the spin recovery chute failed, and both the pilot and test engineer ejected to safety. Rutan still keeps in his office a piece of the F-4’s canopy from the wreckage that actually has his name on it. Eventually a procedure would be devised using the Phantom’s existing landing drag chute, which greatly reduced the rate of unrecoverable flat spins.

Rutan left the air force in 1972. He explains, “Now I could really exercise with my own responsibility, my own authority, my own decision on risk taking with nobody to answer to in developing the VariViggen, the VariEze, the Defiant, the Solitaire, and all these homebuilts. That path could never have accelerated at that rate if I had gone into the space program.”