SOVIET LUNAR FLYBY

Although the Advanced Research Projects Agency had hoped to beat the Soviets to the vicinity of the Moon, by the time Pioneer 4 became the first American probe to do so this particular race had been won by the Soviets. Luna 1 lifted off at 16:41 GMT on 2 January 1959 on a direct ascent trajectory, and on 4 January flew by the Moon at a range of 5,500 km and passed into solar orbit. In fact, the objective was to hit the Moon, but the Soviets gave the impression that the plan had been to make a flyby. The 1.2-metre-diameter 361-kg spherical probe was not stabilised in flight. Its particles and fields instruments included a magnetometer on a 1-metre-long boom. The transmissions continued for 62 hours, by which time it was 600,000 km from Earth. It detected plasma in interplanetary space, further supporting the existence of the solar wind, but no evidence that the Moon possessed a magnetic field.

NASA EMBRACES LUNAR SCIENCE

The term ‘sky science’ was coined by JPL historian Cargill Hall to encompass the study of the Earth’s upper atmosphere and ionosphere, particles and fields in space and micrometeoroid particles. It included solar and cosmic rays, plasma dynamics and the interaction of the solar and terrestrial magnetic fields. By the late 1950s, sky scientists had a range of instruments with which to pursue their interests. These had been developed and refined initially by balloon-borne packages and, more recently, by sounding rockets. Its members were a cohesive group with impeccable academic pedigrees. By way of the National Academy of Sciences they had played key roles in

The charged particles trapped in the Earth’s magnetic field became known as the van Allen radiation belts.

selecting the experiments for the sounding rockets fired by the United States for the International Geophysical Year, and had dominated planning for the Vanguard and Explorer satellites and Pioneer space probes.[8] As a group, they were not interested in physical bodies such as the Moon other than as sources of magnetic fields, and they were certainly not interested in the geological history of the lunar surface.

In early 1958 ‘planetary scientists’ began a series of informal Lunar and Planetary Exploration Colloquia. The first meeting on 13 May 1958 was jointly sponsored by the RAND Corporation, the California Research Corporation and North American Aviation, and it was hosted by the latter in Downey, California. The three principal objectives were (1) to bring together people of common interest for the exchange of scientific and engineering information; (2) to define the scientific and engineering aspects of lunar and planetary exploration and to provide a means for their long­term appraisal; and (3) to make available, nationally, the collective opinions of a qualified group on this subject.[9]

In June 1958 the National Academy of Sciences, a private organisation chartered in 1863 to promote the advancement of science and, when requested, to advise the government on scientific matters, established the Space Science Board, chaired by Lloyd Berkner, to advise the not-yet-active NASA on space research priorities. By the end of 1958, both the President’s Science Advisory Committee and the Space Science Board had cited ‘lunar exploration’ as a worthwhile scientific objective for the new agency.

The only interest in the Moon as a body in its own right expressed by the Pioneer project started by the Advanced Research Projects Agency was to photograph its far-side. But this was not achieved by the Air Force probes, and the discoveries made by the first Army probe led to the deletion of the imaging system of the second probe in order to obtain further particles and fields observations. To be fair, this data was an important contribution to a rapidly developing field of the International Geophysical Year.

The first lunar project authorised by NASA was the Atlas-Able, which was an Air Force launch of a probe supplied by the Space Technology Laboratories. The initial idea had been to use the Atlas, which was much more powerful than the Thor, for a program that would make two launches to send probes towards Venus and then two to insert probes into lunar orbit, but Luna 1’s flyby of the Moon prompted NASA to order the planetary payloads to be replaced by lunar orbiters. The 170-kg probes were to have a spin-stabilised 1-metre-diameter spherical structure with four ‘paddle wheel’ solar arrays around the equator. They would use liquid-propellant engines to make a midcourse correction on the way to the Moon and later to enter orbit around that body. In addition to a suite of particles and fields instruments, they would carry the TV system made for the Thor-launched probes. The first probe was destroyed on 24 September 1959, when the Atlas exploded during a static test. The second lifted off at 07:26 GMT on 26 November from Pad 14 on a direct ascent trajectory, but the aerodynamic shroud protecting the probe failed 45 seconds into the flight. The third lifted off at 15:13 GMT on 25 September I960 from Pad 12, but the first of the two Able stages malfunctioned and fell into the atmosphere 17 minutes after launch. The final probe was launched at 08:40 GMT on 14 December 1960 from Pad 12 but the vehicle exploded 68 seconds later. Although in each case the plan was to enter lunar orbit, most of the 55-kg scientific payload was for particles and fields investigations; indeed, the TV system was deleted from the second pair of probes to accommodate additional radiation detectors. In fact, the Moon was to serve merely as an ‘anchor’ in space away from Earth. In no way could this series of probes be said to constitute ‘lunar exploration’. However, even as the Atlas-Able probes were being developed the situation was changing.

As Assistant Director of the Lewis Laboratory of the National Advisory Council for Aeronautics, in the summer of 1958 Abraham Silverstein played a leading role in the establishment of NASA. When the new agency set up the Office of Space Plight Development at its headquarters, Silverstein became its Director. He promptly hired Homer E. Newell as his assistant for Space Sciences. Newell had joined the Naval Research Laboratory in 1944, and the next year started to conduct research into the upper atmosphere using sounding rockets – in particular investigating the interaction between the magnetic fields of the Sun and Earth. He served as the Science Program Coordinator for the Vanguard project of the International Geophysical Year.

At NASA, Newell created a division staffed by members of the upper atmosphere research group of the Naval Research Laboratory, to organise the agency’s activities in that field. In November, he appointed Robert Jastrow to chair another division to address astronomy, cosmology and planetary sciences. As a sky scientist, Jastrow set out to learn about these topics by visiting the leading proponents.

On reaching the age of 65 in 1958, Harold Urey had retired from the University of Chicago and taken a research position at the University of California at San Diego. He was a member of the Space Science Board of the National Academy of Sciences, and in a paper entitled The Chemistry of the Moon given on 29 October 1958 at the third Lunar and Planetary Exploration Colloquia he had explained the significance of sending a probe to photograph the far-side of the Moon.

When Jastrow visited Urey in early January 1959, Urey emphasised the ‘‘unique importance’’ of the Moon for achieving an understanding of the origin of the planets. As Jastrow recalled of this meeting in his 1967 book Red Giants and White Dwarfs: ‘‘I was fascinated by [his] story, which had never been told to me before in 14 years of study and research in physics.’’ The following week, at Jastrow’s invitation, Urey gave a 2-day presentation at NASA headquarters in which he urged that probes be sent to the Moon. After deliberating, Newell concluded that NASA should initiate a program to study the Moon as an object in its own right. He formed an ad hoc Working Group on Lunar Exploration, with Jastrow in the chair and Urey as a member, to evaluate and recommend experiments which should be placed into orbit around the Moon or landed on its surface. This gave the lunar (and later planetary) scientists a presence at NASA headquarters to match that of the sky scientists.

At that time, JPL was drawing up a proposal for a program of a dozen deep-space missions, of which five would study the Moon. On 5 February 1959 Jastrow sent a contingent to JPL to pass the word that NASA was keen to undertake lunar exploration. The options were for probes to report results as they plunged to their destruction by smashing into the Moon, to enter lunar orbit, and to land instruments on the surface. JPL was authorised to initiate preliminary work. It formed a study group chaired by Albert R. Hibbs.

In fact, in 1959 JPL engineers and scientists were more interested in the challenge of sending probes to Venus and Mars than they were in studying the Moon. There were ‘windows’ for efficiently sending probes to Mars at 25-month intervals and to Venus at 18-month intervals. As the next windows were October I960 for Mars and January 1961 for Venus, the feeling was that the immediate effort should be devoted to these opportunities, rather than the Moon, which could be reached at almost any time. In 1958 JPL had proposed to NASA the development of a new upper stage for the Atlas. This Vega stage would be powered by the engine of the Viking ‘sounding rocket’, modified for ignition in the upper atmosphere. The Atlas-Vega was to be used to launch satellites. A third stage would dispatch deep-space probes. The Soviet lunar flyby in January 1959 spurred the US Congress to authorise the development of the Vega stage. On 30 April JPL sent NASA a 5-year plan of deep-space missions using the Atlas-Vega. The aim was to devote the early effort to flybys of Venus and Mars, and postpone lunar science until 1961. A rough lander would be followed up by an orbiter equipped to investigate the space environment near the Moon and to obtain high-resolution pictures to enable a site for a soft lander to be chosen. Jastrow recommended to Newell the development of a seismometer, communication system and power supply for the package that would be delivered to the lunar surface by the rough landing method. It was later decided to operate a magnetometer, gamma-ray spectrometer and X-ray fluorescence spectrometer during the approach phase. On 25 May 1959, Silverstein and Newell decided to follow the rough lander launched by the Atlas-Vega with two soft landers launched by the Atlas-Centaur, the latter using a powerful stage that was expected to enter service in 1962. In June 1959 Silverstein told JPL to cancel the Mars mission and reassign its launcher to a lunar orbiter.

On 23 July Keith Glennan, Hugh Dryden and Associate Administrator Richard E. Horner met George B. Kistiakowsky, who had succeeded James Killian as Eisenhower’s Special Assistant for Science of Technology, to discuss the objectives of the space program. Glennan warned that slippage in the development of the Vega stage made planetary flights in 1960-1961 impractical. Windows for the Moon were not only more frequent, the flight time was days rather than months. Glennan recommended that the agency focus on lunar missions in order to address the short­term objectives recently specified by the National Security Council’s policy paper, Preliminary US Policy on Outer Space? This was agreed. Several days later, Silverstein cancelled the Venus mission and directed JPL to prepare a new schedule which focused on the Moon. Meanwhile, Newell had established the Lunar and

Document NSC5814/1.

More Soviet successes 53

Planetary Programs Office and transformed Jastrow’s ad hoc Working Group on Lunar Exploration into a standing committee as the Lunar Science Group.