NASA’s Experimental (Mod-0) 100-Kilowatt Wind Turbine Generator (1975-1987)

Подпись: 13Between 1974 and 1988, NASA Lewis led the U. S. program for large wind turbine development, which included the design and installation of 13 power-utility-size turbines. The 13 wind turbines included an ini­tial testbed turbine designated the Mod-0 and 3 generations of followup wind turbines designated Mod-0A/Mod-1, Mod-2, and Mod-5. As noted in the Project Independence task force report, the initial 100-kilowatt wind turbine project and related supporting research was to be performed in­house by NASA Lewis, while the remaining 100-kilowatt systems, mega­watt systems, and large-scale multiunit systems subprograms were to be performed by contractors under NASA Lewis direction. Each succes­sive generation of technology increased reliability and efficiency while reducing the cost of electricity. These advances were made by gaining a better understanding of the system-design drivers, improving the analyt­ical design tools, verifying design methods with operating field data, and incorporating new technology and innovative designs. However, before these systems could be fabricated and installed, NASA Lewis needed to design and construct an experimental testbed wind turbine generator.

NASA’s first experimental wind turbine (the Mod-0) was constructed at Plum Brook Station in Sandusky, OH, and first achieved rated speed and power in December 1975. The initial design of the Mod-0 drew upon some of the previous information from the Smith-Putnam and Hutter-Allgaier turbines. The primary objectives of the Mod-0 wind tur­bine generator were to provide engineering data for future use as a base for the entire Federal Wind Energy Program and to serve as a testbed for the various components and subsystems, including the testing of different design concepts for blades, hubs, pitch-change mechanisms, system controls, and generators. Also, a very important function of the Mod-0 was to validate a number of computer models, codes, tools, and control algorithms.

The Mod-0 was an experimental 100-kilowatt wind turbine gener­ator that at a wind speed of 18 miles per hour (mph) was expected to generate 180,000 kilowatthours of electricity per year in the form of 440-volt, 3-phase, 60-cycle alternating current output. The initial test­bed system, which included two metal blades that were each 62-feet long from hub to blade tip located downwind of the tower, was mounted on a 100-foot, four-legged steel lattice (pinned truss design) tower. The drive train and rotor were in a nacelle with a centerline 100 feet above ground.

The blades, which were built by Lockheed and were based on NASA’s and Lockheed’s experience with airplane wing designs, were capable of pitch change (up and down movement) and full feather (angle of the blade change so that wind resistance is minimized). The hub was of the rigid type, meaning that the blades were bolted to the main shaft. A yaw (deviation from a straight path) control aligned the wind turbine with the wind direction, and pitch control was used for startup, shutdown, and power control functions. When the wind turbine was in a shutdown mode, the blades were feathered and free to slowly rotate. The system was linked to a public utility power network through an automatic syn­chronizer that converted direct current to alternating current.[1500]

Подпись: 13A number of lessons were learned from the Mod-0 testbed. One of the first problems involved the detection of larger than expected blade bending incidents that would have eventually caused early fatigue failure of the blades. The blade bending occurred for both the flatwise (out-of­plane) and edgewise (in-plane) blade positions. Followup study of this problem determined that high blade loads that resulted in the bending of the blades were caused by impulses applied to the blade each time it passed through the wake of the tower. Basically, the pinned truss design of the tower was blocking the airflow to a much greater degree than anticipated. The cause of this problem, which related to the flatwise load factors, was confirmed by site wind measurements and wind tun­nel tower model tests. The initial measure taken to reduce the blocking effect was to remove the stairway from the tower. Eventually, however, NASA developed the soft tube style tower that later became the stan­dard construction method for most wind turbine towers. Followup study of the edgewise blade loads determined that the problem was caused by excessive nacelle yawing (side-to-side) motion. This problem was addressed by replacing a single yaw drive, which aligns the rotor with the wind direction, with a dual yaw drive, and by adding three brakes to the yaw system to provide additional stiffness.[1501]

Both of the above measures reduced the bending problems below the predicted level. Detection of these problems on the testbed Mod-0
resulted in reevaluation of the analytical tools and the subsequent rede­sign of the wind turbine that proved extremely important in the design of NASA’s subsequent horizontal-axis large wind turbines. In regard to other operational testing of the Mod-0 system, NASA engineers determined that the wind turbine controls for speed, power, and yaw worked satisfactorily and that synchronization to the power utility network was successfully demonstrated. Also, the startup, utility operation, shutdown, and standby subsystems worked in a satisfactory manner. Finally, the Mod-0 was used to check out remote operation that was planned for future power utility systems. In summary, the Mod-0 project satisfied its primary objective of providing the entire Federal Wind Energy Program with early oper­ations and performance data and through continued experience with testing new concepts and components. While NASA Lewis was ready to move forward with fabrication of its next level Mod-0A and Mod-1 wind turbines, the Mod-0 testbed continued to provide valuable testing of new configurations, components, and concepts for over 11 more years.